I was wondering – recently my husband heard that there were contradicting accounts of the First Vision from the Prophet Joseph Smith. Do you know anything about this? This is very disheartening to my husband and I’m at a loss.. not sure what to do. Any info would be great! Thanks! -
Becky, from Orlando, Florida
Of course there are conflicting accounts of the First Vision, in which God the Father, and His Son, Jesus Christ appeared to the fourteen-year-old boy Joseph Smith, in answer to his fervent prayer asking which of all the churches was right. That vision occurred in the spring of 1820. The earliest extant account of the First Vision in the grove is that written by the Prophet eighteen later, in 1838.
It was first published by Joseph Smith in The Times and Seasons in 1842. However, in that same year, and some time before the publication of The Times and Seasons, J. B. Turner, a non-Mormon, published a book in which he gave an account of the First Vision. His version, although it contains some errors of date, corroborates the Prophet’s account (see John A. Widtsoe, Evidences and Reconciliations, p.336).
Joseph first related the account of his vision to his own mother on the day that it happened.. How many times to you think that the account of the first vision was related and passed from one person to another in the twenty-two year period between its occurrence and its publication? You must also remember that in the early 1800s there were no computers, no Xerox machines and no typewriters. Hand written copies of verbal accounts as they were remembered by the listeners were the only way, other than verbal communication, of relaying information.
So your husband needs to feel no concern if various accounts of historic events of those days contain some discrepancies. In truth, there were many discrepancies. Brigham Young, in referring to the written accounts of his sermons, is reported to have said, “I only wish that they would write what I said.”
My husband is disheartened by reported contradicting accounts of the First Vision by Joseph Smith.
filter by category
All Abortion Addictions Afterlife Babies Baptism Bible Blessings Blog Book of Mormon Brigham Young Callings Church History Current issues Death Depression Divorce Doctrine & Covenants Education Etymology Faith Family Family History Family Roots Forgiveness God Gratitude Happiness Health Hobbies Holy Ghost Homosexuality Jesus Christ Joseph Smith Knowledge LDS Church LDS Scriptures Life's Lessons Love Marriage Miracles Miscellaneous Missionary Work Mormon Mormon Doctrine Mormon Faith Mormon Policy Music Natural Phenomena Obedience Offerings Pearl of Great Price Personal Revelation Personal Searching Podcast Prayer Premortal Life Preparedness Priesthood Prophets Repentance Revelation Sabbath Day Sacrament Satan Scriptures Second Coming Self Worth Sexual Issues Temples Testimony Tithing Trials Word of Wisdom World History Worthiness
December 12, 2013 7:55 am
Question Hi Gramps, Will the church bend to homosexual pressure and allow openly gay men into the priesthood? The RLDS have done so. I’m fearful of it. Josh ... (more)
December 11, 2013 8:06 am
Question Gramps, I understand that there will be mortals during the Millenium until they grow old as a tree. They will not die but will be changed to their immortal... (more)
December 10, 2013 7:14 am
Question Hi Gramps, My husband and I have four boys together, 11, 9, 8, 6. We were married in the temple 6 months after returning from our missions. My husband’s brother... (more)
December 9, 2013 6:54 am
Question Gramps, We have a friend who is taking the discussions. His assignment last week was to read Enos. He had an interesting question. He asked if Enos was ever... (more)
December 8, 2013 12:46 am
Question Gramps, After Lucifer and 1/3 part of the angels were cast out, I assume that Satan wanted to do everything he could to keep us from returning to Heavenly... (more)
December 7, 2013 6:30 am
Question Gramps, If the leadership in Salt Lake City have not given guidelines on a given topic, can a local unit make policy? For instance, old Primary guidelines precluded snacks... (more)
December 6, 2013 5:45 am
Question Gramps, I wonder what the difference is if someone with the priesthood prays for someone who is sick and they get healed compared to a preacher in another church... (more)
December 5, 2013 6:07 am
Question Dear Gramps, I have a lusting problem. Fortunately, I don’t have a pornography problem. I have tried and tried and tried for over 30 years now to overcome looking... (more)
December 4, 2013 8:31 am
Question Dear Gramps, This is my first time asking someone questions like this other than the Lord of course. My mother shortly got converted after I did. She was happy,... (more)
December 3, 2013 6:41 am
Question Gramps, Hi, I am a member of the church. I am just trying to understand how to use the Joseph Smith translation of the Bible and combine it... (more)
December 2, 2013 7:01 am
Question Dear Gramps, I was wondering if there is any archaeological evidence to support things mentioned in the Book of Mormon such as wheat, barley, copper, and steel in America?... (more)